Manchester United defender Lisandro Martinez has responded strongly to criticism from former club midfielder Paul Scholes, challenging the United legend to speak to him directly rather than through television commentary.
Martinez made the remarks following Manchester United’s impressive 2–0 victory over rivals Manchester City on Saturday, a result that boosted morale at Old Trafford and strengthened belief within the squad after a mixed run of performances.
The Argentine centre-back, known for his aggressive style and fearless approach, was one of United’s standout performers in the derby, playing a crucial role in keeping City’s dangerous attack quiet. After the match, Martinez addressed comments previously made by Scholes, who has been openly critical of United’s defensive performances in recent months.
Speaking candidly, Martinez made it clear that outside opinions do not distract him, insisting that his main focus remains on delivering results on the pitch.
“He can say whatever he wants,” Martinez said.
“I told him already, if he wants to say something to me, he can come to me wherever he wants. To my house, wherever. I don’t care.”
The 26-year-old emphasized that while he respects former players who genuinely want to support the club, he believes criticism should be constructive and personal rather than delivered solely through media platforms.
“I respect the relationships when they want to help the club because everyone can talk on television,” he added.
“But when you see them here at the club face-to-face, no one says anything in your face.
“So I don’t really care what they say. I just put the focus on my performance.”
Martinez’s comments reflect growing tension between current Manchester United players and sections of the club’s former stars who regularly analyze matches on television. Over the years, legends such as Scholes, Roy Keane, and Gary Neville have become prominent pundits, often offering blunt assessments of the team’s struggles.
While many fans appreciate the honesty of former players, others believe the constant criticism places unnecessary pressure on the squad, especially during periods of rebuilding.
The derby victory over Manchester City came at a crucial moment for United. After an inconsistent start to the season, the win provided renewed confidence and showcased the team’s ability to rise to big occasions. Goals from key attackers sealed the result, while the defense delivered one of its most disciplined performances of the campaign.
Martinez, returning to full fitness after injury setbacks, appeared sharp, aggressive, and composed throughout the match. His partnership at the back helped limit City’s attacking rhythm, frustrating their forwards and cutting off passing lanes through midfield.
For United supporters, the performance was a reminder of why the club invested heavily in the Argentine international. Since arriving from Ajax, Martinez has earned admiration for his commitment, leadership, and willingness to confront challenges head-on.
However, his style has also drawn criticism, with some pundits questioning his height and physical suitability for the Premier League. Scholes has previously suggested that Martinez can be targeted by stronger opponents, comments that the defender clearly has not forgotten.
Rather than responding with silence, Martinez chose to confront the criticism directly, underlining his belief that performance matters more than public opinion.
Inside the club, sources suggest that manager Erik ten Hag has encouraged his players to block out external noise and remain united. The Dutch coach, who previously worked with Martinez at Ajax, has consistently defended the defender and praised his mentality.
Ten Hag has often highlighted Martinez’s winning attitude, describing him as a player who sets standards in training and matches alike.
The City victory may mark a turning point in United’s season. With crucial fixtures ahead both domestically and in Europe, consistency remains the biggest challenge. Performances like Saturday’s will be required regularly if the club hopes to compete for trophies.
Martinez’s outspoken comments have also sparked debate among fans. While some believe his words show passion and leadership, others argue that public confrontations with club legends risk unnecessary controversy.
Still, many supporters view his attitude as a reflection of modern footballers who are unafraid to defend themselves in the media. In an era where criticism spreads instantly across television and social media, players are increasingly choosing to respond rather than remain silent.
For Paul Scholes, his remarks were consistent with his long-standing approach as a pundit, offering unfiltered analysis regardless of reputation. The former England midfielder has repeatedly stated that his loyalty lies with the club, not individual players.
Whether the exchange escalates further remains to be seen. For now, Martinez appears content letting his football speak louder than opinions.
“I just put the focus on my performance,” he said, summing up his mindset.
As Manchester United prepare for their next fixtures, attention will shift back to results on the pitch. If Martinez continues to deliver performances like the one against Manchester City, criticism may gradually fade, replaced by renewed respect for a defender who thrives on intensity and confrontation.
The derby win reminded fans of United’s potential when discipline, unity, and belief come together. For Martinez, it was more than just three points. It was a statement of resilience, pride, and determination to succeed at one of the world’s biggest football clubs.
For more breaking sports news and updates, follow Africa Live News on all official platforms:
Website: https://www.africalivenews.com
X: https://x.com/africalivenews2
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Africalivenews
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/africalivenews
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@africalivenews.com
Stay connected for trusted reporting, exclusive stories, and in-depth football coverage across Africa and beyond.
