Veteran music producer ID Cabasa has taken a stand against Jamaican reggae icon Buju Banton’s recent criticism of Afrobeats, which Banton described as a “shallow and unsubstantial music genre.” In August, Banton argued that Afrobeats fails to highlight the struggles of Africa, despite its growing global recognition and popularity.
During a memorial lecture for the late cleric Denis Joseph Slattery in Lagos, Cabasa addressed Banton’s comments, asserting that the Jamaican singer lacks a true understanding of the Afrobeat genre’s language and style. “Buju Banton does not understand the genre. Can he speak our language? No,” Cabasa stated firmly, emphasizing that the cultural nuances embedded in Afrobeats may be lost on those outside the Nigerian context.
He elaborated on the unique storytelling approach prevalent in Nigerian music, particularly Afrobeats, which often employs sarcasm and wit. “When you go online, Nigerians are the most sarcastic people in the world. So when you don’t understand our sarcasm and how we tell our stories, you will think there is no story to it,” Cabasa explained. This perspective underscores the richness of Afrobeats, which combines diverse influences and contemporary themes to engage listeners both locally and internationally.
Cabasa pointed out that the new generation of artists presents profound truths in a manner that resonates with their audience. He highlighted the lyrical depth found in the works of artists like Burna Boy, BNXN (also known as Buju), Olamide, and Asake. “You listen to Burna, BNXN, that we call Buju. You listen to Olamide and Asake. Are you going to tell me that there’s no substance in what Asake is doing?” he questioned, challenging the notion that Afrobeats lacks depth or meaning.
His remarks serve as a rebuttal to Banton’s assertion, suggesting that depth can manifest in various forms and styles, and that understanding these nuances requires an appreciation of the cultural context from which they arise. Cabasa also conveyed a sense of frustration with Banton’s remarks, noting that a lack of understanding does not warrant criticism. “That you don’t understand a lot doesn’t mean that you should just criticize it,” he asserted.
The conversation surrounding Afrobeats continues to evolve as the genre gains traction worldwide. Artists are not only achieving commercial success but are also shaping cultural dialogues, bringing African stories and experiences to the forefront of the global music scene. As such, criticism from established figures like Buju Banton raises questions about the understanding and appreciation of diverse musical expressions.
Cabasa’s defense of Afrobeats resonates with many who see the genre as a powerful vehicle for storytelling, culture, and identity. The genre’s ability to fuse various influences while maintaining its roots in African culture highlights its complexity and significance. As more artists emerge and explore the boundaries of Afrobeats, the narrative surrounding the genre will likely continue to expand, challenging preconceived notions and encouraging deeper engagement.
In a broader context, the exchange between Cabasa and Banton reflects a generational divide in music appreciation and production. As the industry evolves, established artists may find it challenging to connect with newer styles and trends, leading to misunderstandings and mischaracterizations. This dynamic calls for a more open dialogue between different musical traditions, fostering mutual respect and understanding.
As the global music industry grapples with the rise of Afrobeats, it is essential for artists and producers to continue advocating for the genre’s recognition and legitimacy. The conversations surrounding its depth and substance should not only acknowledge the artistic merit of Afrobeats but also celebrate its role in representing African voices and experiences on a global stage.
Ultimately, ID Cabasa’s defense of Afrobeats highlights the importance of cultural context in music criticism. By challenging Buju Banton’s views, Cabasa encourages a deeper exploration of the genre, advocating for a recognition of its value beyond surface-level interpretations. As Afrobeats continues to thrive and influence global music trends, it will be crucial for critics and artists alike to engage in thoughtful discourse that appreciates the richness and diversity inherent in this vibrant genre.
