The New York State Catholic Conference has strongly criticized former U.S. President Donald Trump for sharing an artificial intelligence (AI)-generated image of himself dressed as the pope, calling the act disrespectful and insensitive—especially during the period of mourning for Pope Francis, who was recently laid to rest.
The controversial image was posted by Trump on his official Truth Social account on Saturday, sparking outrage across religious communities, particularly among Roman Catholics. The digitally altered photo, which depicts Trump wearing papal robes and appearing as the head of the Catholic Church, quickly went viral across major social media platforms including X (formerly Twitter), Instagram, and Facebook.
Catholic Conference: “Do Not Mock Us”
Reacting publicly via its official X handle, the New York State Catholic Conference expressed profound disappointment in Trump’s post, condemning it as inappropriate and offensive given the gravity of the moment within the Catholic Church.
“There is nothing clever or funny about this image, Mr. President,” the conference stated. “We just buried our beloved Pope Francis, and the cardinals are about to enter a solemn conclave to elect a new successor of St. Peter. Do not mock us.”
The post immediately drew support from clergy and Catholic faithful across the United States and beyond, many of whom said the image trivialized the papal office and disrespected the sacred mourning period that precedes the election of a new pope.
Timing Adds to the Controversy
The outrage has been further intensified by the timing of the post. Pope Francis, who passed away earlier this month, was buried in St. Peter’s Basilica following days of mourning and international tributes. The Vatican is now preparing for a papal conclave, set to begin Wednesday, where cardinals from across the globe will gather in the Sistine Chapel to elect the next pope.
Trump’s decision to post a digitally created image of himself appearing to claim the role of pontiff came just as Catholic communities worldwide were reflecting on Francis’ legacy and praying for spiritual guidance in the selection of a new pope.
“The image was not only distasteful but profoundly disrespectful to Catholics everywhere,” said Father Michael Scanlon, a parish priest in Albany. “We are in a sacred period of prayer and discernment. To use this moment for mockery or self-promotion is unconscionable.”
Social Media Backlash
Within hours of its release, the AI-generated photo became a trending topic, with reactions split between amusement, criticism, and disbelief. While some of Trump’s supporters praised the image as humorous or symbolic, the broader response has been overwhelmingly critical—particularly among religious leaders, Catholic groups, and ethicists concerned about the use of AI in misleading or inflammatory ways.
“Deepfake images like this risk blurring the line between reality and parody in dangerous ways,” said Dr. Angela Romero, a media ethics professor at Fordham University. “When shared by a figure of influence like a former president—especially during a time of religious sensitivity—it becomes more than just a joke. It’s a message.”
Trump, who has not issued a follow-up comment or apology as of press time, is no stranger to using digital imagery and memes on his social media platforms to engage followers and criticize opponents. However, many believe this instance crossed a line.
“This wasn’t just political theater,” said Sister Bernadette Hughes, a Catholic nun based in New York. “It was an affront to every Catholic grieving the loss of Pope Francis. The Church is not a prop.”
Legacy of Pope Francis and the Conclave Ahead
The backlash to Trump’s post comes as Catholics across the globe remember the life and teachings of Pope Francis, the first pontiff from Latin America and a figure known for his emphasis on humility, social justice, and interfaith dialogue.
Elected in 2013, Pope Francis broke numerous traditions, emphasizing compassion over condemnation and often speaking out on issues like climate change, poverty, and global migration. His death has left a significant void, and the upcoming conclave is viewed as a crucial moment for the future direction of the Catholic Church.
With 120 cardinal-electors set to enter the conclave this week, the Vatican is once again at the center of the world’s attention. The process is steeped in ritual and secrecy, and the faithful are anxiously waiting for the traditional white smoke from the Sistine Chapel chimney, signaling the election of the next leader of the global Church.
“During a time like this, when billions of Catholics are praying for guidance and unity, we expect leaders—especially global ones—to show respect,” said Cardinal Joseph Adutwum, speaking from Rome. “The papacy is sacred. Mocking it for internet clicks is not leadership.”
Broader Implications for Religious and Political Discourse
This incident has reignited broader conversations about the intersection of politics, religion, and digital media. Critics argue that the line between satire and sacrilege is often ignored in pursuit of viral attention, particularly by high-profile figures who understand the power of images in shaping public opinion.
“There’s nothing wrong with satire,” said Rev. Thomas Kerrigan, a theologian and author based in Boston. “But when it comes at the expense of a grieving community or sacred institution, it ceases to be satire and becomes cruelty.”
Political analysts suggest that Trump’s post may also alienate religious voters, a key demographic in American elections. While Trump has historically enjoyed support from many evangelical Christians, his relationship with the Catholic Church has been more complex.
“This move won’t play well with Catholic voters, especially older and more devout ones,” said Lisa Callahan, a senior political strategist. “He may have thought it was humorous, but to many, it looked like mockery.”
Moving Forward
As the Catholic Church prepares for one of its most solemn and spiritually significant moments, the hope among its leaders is for peace, unity, and reverence.
“The world is watching,” the New York State Catholic Conference wrote in a follow-up post. “Let us all—regardless of faith—approach this moment with dignity and respect.”
For now, the digital image of Donald Trump in papal attire remains etched into the week’s headlines, a viral controversy that has become yet another flashpoint in the ongoing debate over decorum, AI, and the responsibilities of public figures in a divided world.
